A possible Ph.D. Thesis for someone

When studying the Montanists we have to recognise that the majority of the information we have comes from their opponents, who recycled the same accusations slightly different forms (See John De Soyres work []). These snippets hardly paint a balanced picture. For example:

1) Monatus was a recent convert [i.e. not grounded in the faith – bound to be led astray into error]

2) He was from Phrygia [They are all mad there]

3) His first converts were of the female gender [Weak-willed and easily deceived]

4) They left their husbands [Shame on them!]

5) He prophesied that the new Jerusalem would descend in Phrygia [the arrogant cheek!]

6) The Montanists introduce new fasts and forbid certain foods [Think that innovation is a sign of inspiration]

It appears to me that the opponents of Montanism may well be using stock accusations used of other heresies in their attacks. Is suspect that this article may be relevant here:

V. Burrus, “The Heretical Woman as Symbol in (bishop) Alexander, Athanasius, Epiphanius, and Jerome,” Harvard Theological Review 84 (1991): 229-48.

I think that it would make a good Ph.D thesis for someone to examine all the accusations made against the Montanists and see whether the same charges were made against other heresies in order to test this theory.

Please let me know if you take up the challenge.

Rob Bradshaw

Published by
Rob Bradshaw

Recent Posts

Translations of Early Documents

Translations of Early Documents

From around 1917 to 1927 the Society for the Promotion of Christian Knowledge (SPCK) published…

2 weeks ago

Letters of Augustine of Hippo

Today's free book is a recently out-of-copyright translation of the letters of Augustine of Hippo.…

1 year ago

Studies in Arianism by Henry Melvill Gwatkin

Today's free book is a series of seven studies by Henry Gwatkin on Arianism. This…

2 years ago

Gwatkin’s History of the Church to 313AD

Today's free book is Henry Gwatkin's History of the Church up to the time of…

2 years ago

Irenaeus of Lugdunum (Lyons) by F.R. Montgomery Hitchcock

Ireneaus was a Second Century Bishop of Lugdunum in what is today southern France. He…

2 years ago

Clement of Alexandria by R.B. Tollinton, 2 Vols.

Today's free book is Richard Bertram Tollinton's substantial work on the life of Origen's predecessor…

2 years ago